Skip to content 
In the field of power transmission and distribution, circuit breakers are indispensable. This is because they can protect the system from overloads, short circuits, and ground faults. Among the various types, disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs et air circuit breakers are two prominent choices. For engineers, project managers, and industry professionals responsible for selecting appropriate equipment for power systems, understanding the differences between air circuit breakers and vacuum circuit breakers is crucial. The choice between them can have a significant impact on the reliability, maintenance costs, and long-term performance of the system. In this blog, we will delve into their core definitions and key differences, and clarify the distinctions between vacuum circuit breakers and air circuit breakers through insights from practical applications.
Un outdoor vacuum circuit breaker is a type of power switch equipment specifically designed for outdoor environments, using vacuum as the arc extinguishing medium. Unlike indoor vacuum circuit breakers, this model has been specially designed to withstand harsh outdoor conditions, thanks to its sturdy weatherproof casing. Its core component is the vacuum arc extinguishing chamber, which maintains extremely low pressure inside. When the conductive contacts separate, the arc extinguishes here. The excellent dielectric strength of vacuum ensures that the arc can be quickly extinguished even under high voltages, making disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs highly suitable for medium and high voltage applications. Top manufacturers prioritize the use of durable materials and sealed designs to protect internal components from environmental damage, thus ensuring stable performance even in unprotected environments.
An air circuit breaker is a type of circuit protection device that mainly utilizes air as the arc extinguishing and insulation medium. Unlike disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs, ACB relies on the atmospheric air within the sealed compartment to extinguish the arc when the contacts are disconnected. Under electrical stress, air is easily ionized, which helps with arc extinguishing. ACB is typically designed for low-voltage (LT) applications, with its rated voltage reaching up to 690 volts, and is often used in indoor areas such as distribution panels, industrial control rooms, and building electrical systems.
The fundamental difference lies in their arc-extinguishing media. Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur utilize the characteristic that vacuum cannot sustain free electrons and thus can quickly extinguish the arc. In contrast, air circuit breakers rely on atmospheric air as the medium. During the formation of the arc, the air becomes ionized, and the arc guide rails help break the arc into manageable parts. This difference directly affects their performance under different voltage levels and environmental conditions.
Voltage and Application Range
Extérieur disjoncteurs à vide perform exceptionally well in medium and high voltage applications, with their rated voltages typically ranging from 11 kilovolts to 33 kilovolts. They are highly suitable for outdoor power transmission lines, substation feeders, and renewable energy facilities. This is because high voltage handling is crucial in these scenarios. In contrast, air circuit breakers are limited to low-voltage applications (≤ 690 volts) and are mainly used in indoor low-voltage motor control centers (MCCs), secondary feeders of power transformers, and building electrical systems. The difference between a vacuum circuit breaker and an air circuit breaker here is clear: VCBs handle high voltage outdoors, while ACBs manage low voltage indoors.
Le outdoor vacuum circuit breaker is specifically designed for outdoor use. Its weatherproof casing can withstand rain, dust, extreme temperatures, and corrosion. They perform well in unprotected environments such as utility poles, substations, and remote power sites. However, the disjoncteur pneumatique is purely an indoor device, and its design cannot withstand the influence of outdoor factors. When choosing between these two types of equipment, the installation environment is a factor that cannot be ignored.
The maintenance requirements for disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs are extremely low. The vacuum interrupter chamber of these breakers is designed with a sealed structure, which can prevent contamination and wear. Therefore, they usually only require routine inspections. If the vacuum seal fails, the interrupter chamber must be replaced, but this situation is extremely rare. Air circuit breakers, on the other hand, require more frequent maintenance. They need to check if there is any leakage in the gas chamber, as the arc channel may accumulate dust, and the contacts may wear over time and require cleaning or replacement. Additionally, air circuit breakers do not require gas replenishment, while if the gas chamber of a vacuum circuit breaker fails, it cannot automatically restore the vacuum environment.
Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur have a longer service life and a higher breaking frequency. The sealed design of the vacuum interrupter can minimize contact wear to the greatest extent, allowing it to operate thousands of times without performance degradation. This is particularly suitable for applications that require frequent breaking. Air circuit breakers have a shorter service life and lower breaking capacity because the arc channel and contacts wear out faster due to repeated exposure to arcs.
Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur are often smaller and lighter than air circuit breakers at the same voltage level. Due to the more streamlined design of vacuum circuit breakers, they are easier to install in outdoor areas with limited space. In contrast, air circuit breakers have larger and heavier volumes because they are equipped with curved guide slots and gas chambers, so they require dedicated indoor space for installation.
Moderne disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs usually have features such as overcurrent protection, ground fault detection, and remote monitoring. Brands like Chuanli integrate intelligent sensors and communication modules, enabling real-time data tracking and remote operation. Air circuit breakers have basic protection but are less equipped with intelligent integrated functions because their low-voltage applications focus more on simplicity rather than advanced connectivity.
The initial cost of disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs is usually higher than that of air circuit breakers. This is because the precise manufacturing of vacuum circuit breakers and the need for a weatherproof casing require additional costs. However, their lower maintenance requirements and longer service life result in lower long-term ownership costs over time. Air circuit breakers have a lower initial cost, but due to the need for frequent maintenance and a shorter replacement cycle, their long-term costs are higher.
Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur have outstanding safety performance in high-voltage environments. The vacuum medium can prevent arc leakage and reduce the risk of fire. They perform well in handling common faults in high-voltage systems, such as double grounding faults and phase current interruption. Air circuit breakers are suitable for low-voltage applications, but if the arc channel is damaged, the arc can persist more easily. Their indoor design limits their fault handling capabilities to only minor overcurrent or short circuit situations.
Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur have higher energy efficiency. Due to the use of a vacuum medium, their dielectric loss is extremely low. During operation, they consume less electricity and generate almost negligible heat. Therefore, they are highly suitable for systems that emphasize energy efficiency, such as renewable energy grids. In contrast, air circuit breakers have higher dielectric loss due to the properties of air, and the arc extinguishing in air generates more heat.
Disjoncteurs à vide pour l'extérieur are more suitable for integration into smart grids because their outdoor deployment and high-voltage handling methods meet the requirements of modern automated power systems. Many of its features can seamlessly integrate with the grid management platform. However, air circuit breakers have poorer compatibility with smart grids because their low-voltage, indoor usage scenarios usually do not require advanced automation or remote monitoring functions.
| Fonctionnalité | Disjoncteur pour aspirateur extérieur | Air Circuit Breaker |
| Arc Quenching Medium | Le vide | Atmospheric air |
| Plage de tension | 11 kV – 33 kV+ | ≤690 volts |
| Installation | Outdoor (weatherproof) | Indoor only |
| Maintenance | Minimal (sealed vacuum interrupter) | Frequent (arc chute cleaning, contact checks) |
| Switching Life | High (thousands of operations) | Moderate (limited by contact/arc chute wear) |
| Size/Weight | Compact, lightweight | Bulky, heavier |
| Smart Integration | Advanced (remote monitoring, sensors) | Basic (limited connectivity) |
| TCO | Lower (high upfront, low maintenance) | Higher (low upfront, high maintenance) |
| Best For | High-voltage outdoor systems (transmission, renewables) | Low-voltage indoor systems (buildings, light industry) |
Le outdoor vacuum circuit breaker de Chuanli Company is specially designed for operation in the harshest outdoor conditions. It features a rust-proof casing, high-temperature-resistant components, and a sealed vacuum arc-extinguishing device, which enables it to maintain stable performance in extremely hot, extremely cold, rainy, or dusty environments. It is an ideal choice for remote power stations and the public power grid.
Chuanli pays great attention to the durability of the products during the design process. As a result, its outdoor vacuum circuit breaker does not require frequent maintenance. The sealed vacuum circuit breaker can prevent contamination, and the sturdy structure reduces the need for regular inspections or component replacements, which saves time and costs for the operators.
Chuanli‘s outdoor vacuum circuit breaker boasts outstanding switching capabilities, capable of quickly extinguishing arcs and handling high voltage currents and faults. Its fast response time ensures reduced downtime in case of faults, protecting critical power facilities and minimizing losses.
Chuanli has integrated intelligent technology into its disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs, including remote monitoring, real-time fault diagnosis, and compatibility with the smart grid platform. These features enable operators to manage the system efficiently, reduce manual intervention, and meet the requirements of modern power automation.
A regional utility company recently upgraded its outdoor power transmission lines and replaced the old low-voltage AC circuit breakers in the remote substations with disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs de Chuanli Company. The company was facing frequent circuit breaker maintenance issues and limited voltage handling capabilities. After installing the vacuum circuit breakers from Chuanli Company, the company reported a 70% reduction in maintenance costs and no more unexpected downtime. This case demonstrates that the disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs de Chuanli Company perform better than air circuit breakers in outdoor high-voltage applications, providing long-term value and reliability.
When choosing between disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs et air circuit breakers, the key factor depends on the voltage requirements of your application, the installation environment, and the long-term operation goals. For outdoor high-voltage systems, disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs are unparalleled in terms of reliability, low maintenance costs, and performance. This is especially true when they come from a reliable brand like Chuanli. Chuanli’s commitment to quality, innovation, and customer-centric design ensures that its disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs can meet the needs of modern power systems. Whether you are building a new substation, upgrading existing infrastructure, or expanding renewable energy projects, Chuanli‘s vacuum circuit breakers can provide the durability and functionality necessary to keep the power system running smoothly.
Are you ready to upgrade your power system with reliable high-performance circuit breakers? Choose Chuanli‘s disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs to meet your outdoor high-voltage needs, or trust our expertise to find the correct solution for indoor low-voltage applications. Contact Chuanli today to learn more about our product range and take the first step towards a more efficient and reliable power system!
Q1: Can air circuit breakers be used outdoors?
A1 :No, air circuit breakers are only designed for indoor use. Their components do not have the ability to withstand outdoor factors, which may lead to corrosion, arc extinguishing failure, and safety hazards. For outdoor applications, disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs are the correct choice.
Q2: What are the main differences between vacuum circuit breakers and air circuit breakers in terms of voltage handling?
A2 :The key difference lies in the voltage range. Vacuum circuit breakers can handle medium-high voltages (11 kV to 33 kV and above), while air circuit breakers are limited to low voltages (≤ 690 V). This makes vacuum circuit breakers suitable for power transmission, while air circuit breakers are suitable for indoor distribution.
Q3: Are outdoor vacuum circuit breakers more expensive than air circuit breakers?
A3 :Although the initial cost of disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs is higher, they require the least maintenance, have a longer lifespan, and avoid the cost of frequent replacements of air circuit breakers. For long-term projects, vacuum circuit breakers are more valuable.
Q4: Does Chali’s outdoor vacuum circuit breaker have intelligent functions?
A4 :Yes, Chuanli‘s disjoncteurs à vide extérieurs have intelligent functions such as remote monitoring, real-time fault diagnosis, and compatibility with intelligent grid automation systems. These functions improve operational efficiency and reduce manual intervention.
